Qaddafi is most assuredly a vicious tyrant, and his ouster is a worthy goal. But it will not be achieved through incremental aid to the rebels and intermittent decapitation attempts. Yet we are where we are. Given its current level of commitment, the United States should continue to use its military capabilities to support the no-fly zone, monitor and publicize killings of civilians by Qaddafi's forces or the rebels, and respond with direct force to prevent or mitigate any mass atrocities. More importantly, however, the administration should work toward a negotiated end to the civil war, while starting to plan for the U.S. military assets, humanitarian assistance, and financial aid required to keep any peace.Sounds like the Yugoslavian intervention at best, Iraq at worst. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Showing posts with label Libya. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Libya. Show all posts
Friday, April 29, 2011
Oops
Micah Zenko has a very discouraging piece in the online magazine Foreign Policy , in which he lays out all the reasons why we goofed in assuming that Britain, France, and the Arab League could topple Qadaffi in "days, not weeks" of U.S. assistance with the no-fly zone. Didn't work out that way, did it? Here's his final, downbeat paragraph:
Thursday, April 21, 2011
A casualty of war
Shantih (peace) to Tim Hetherington, who was killed on Wednesday along with another photographer in the besieged Libyan city of Misurata. Mr. Hetherington was the director of the excellent Afghan documentary Restrepo
. That movie was a joint project between him and Sebastian Junger, who wrote of him: "working with Tim was like climbing into a little sports car and driving around really, really fast." Pity it had to crash!
Mr. Junger's contribution to their joint legacy was a superlative book with a simple and eloquent title: War
. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Mr. Junger's contribution to their joint legacy was a superlative book with a simple and eloquent title: War
Monday, April 4, 2011
Here's an idea: a constitutional dictatorship!
Like a rotten log rolled over, the government of Libya keeps offering new surprises, as the insects scurry to find new and safer positions. Now that the wonderfully named Moussa Koussa has "defected" to England, Col Gadhafi is said to rely more and more upon his sons, much like the late Saddam Hussein in Iraq. And, like Saddam, Gadhafi has a whole bunch of sons. Now two of them have offered a suggestion that for chutzpah exceeds anything that Saddam ever proposed: they'll shove the old man aside and themselves preside over Libya as it transitions to democracy.
Right! Call it a constitutional dictatorship: members of the family will take turns at repressing Libya. No doubt some of Gadafi's seven sons themselves have sons, and so on. They can keep passing the dictatorship down from generation to generation, all the while abiding by the new constitution. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Right! Call it a constitutional dictatorship: members of the family will take turns at repressing Libya. No doubt some of Gadafi's seven sons themselves have sons, and so on. They can keep passing the dictatorship down from generation to generation, all the while abiding by the new constitution. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Tuesday, March 29, 2011
Now Gaddafi can breath again!
I suppose it's churlish of me, after weeks of urging that our Follower in Chief get off the dime and do something to help the Libyan rebels, to complain about Mr Obama's apologetic declaration of war--er, kinetic action--last night. So I'll just pass along this, from NBC News via Newsbusters (boldface as on the website):
WILLIE GEIST: What's the reaction there [in Libya], though, not only from the rebels but if any from Colonel Gaddafi to what the president said last night about not wanting to wait to see images of mass graves and slaughter of civilians before he intervened? What are they saying there?The video is on the Newsbusters site. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
JIM MACEDA: Well, there hasn't been any official comment, Willie, from Gaddafi or from the regime or from the compound, yet. I can tell you that the whole, the atmospherics here of the government officials and minders is very different. They had gone to ground for a number of days: very quiet, very tense. They're looking much more themselves: much more bellicose, much more defiant in the past 24 hours. I would think, it's an educated guess but I would say that Gaddafi, after hearing that speech ... that the regime now is feeling a lot better. That they're feeling that they dodged a bullet. If NATO's taking over, they like that. They've got much better relations with NATO than with the United States in general. And they love the idea that the US position as stated by Obama is that they're not looking for regime change. Soon as he heard that, I'm sure Gaddafi was quite excited. He thinks he can probably negotiate his way out of this as he has over the past 41 years in other situations.
Sunday, March 27, 2011
We can breath again
According to the New York Times this morning, anti-Qaddafi forces are on the march again in Libya, apparently retaking the town of Ajdabiya, which controls access to the country's eastern shore. There's a useful map here. Libya has two strips of Mediterranean shore, separated by a gigantic bight, the Gulf of Sidra. The interior is notable largely for the Sahara Desert, much fought over during World War II in a contest to control the shoreline.
This geographical curiosity is what makes our no-fly zone feasible, and also explains the importance of Ajdabiya. If the rebels can clear the Qaddafi forces out of the eastern part of the country, and if Europe and the United States grant them diplomatic recognition, then they can probably hold on for the long haul. By the same token, Qaddafi may well hold on to the western part of the country. The momentum for actually unseating him may have leached away already. Mr Obama, in his radio address yesterday, allowed that “We are succeeding in our mission.” But he coyly refrains from defining what that mission is. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
This geographical curiosity is what makes our no-fly zone feasible, and also explains the importance of Ajdabiya. If the rebels can clear the Qaddafi forces out of the eastern part of the country, and if Europe and the United States grant them diplomatic recognition, then they can probably hold on for the long haul. By the same token, Qaddafi may well hold on to the western part of the country. The momentum for actually unseating him may have leached away already. Mr Obama, in his radio address yesterday, allowed that “We are succeeding in our mission.” But he coyly refrains from defining what that mission is. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Saturday, March 26, 2011
The commander who won't
I voted for Barack Obama in the New Hampshire primary, in large part because his speeches thrilled me as no other presidential candidate in my lifetime. (Jack Kennedy came close.) By November however I had become disenchanted, and now I'm just befuddled. Where is the great speechifier of 2008? Peggy Noonan asks the same question in the Wall Street Journal today, and asks it better than I ever could:
I cannot for the life of me see how an American president can launch a serious military action without a full and formal national address in which he explains to the American people why he is doing what he is doing, why it is right, and why it is very much in the national interest. He referred to his aims in parts of speeches and appearances when he was in South America, but now he's home. More is needed, more is warranted, and more is deserved. He has to sit at that big desk and explain his thinking, put forward the facts as he sees them, and try to garner public support. He has to make a case for his own actions. It's what presidents do! And this is particularly important now, because there are reasons to fear the current involvement will either escalate and produce a lengthy conflict or collapse and produce humiliation.Unlike me, Noonan is skeptical of our military action in Libya. (I only fret that it came too late.) But she is spot on--actually very gentle--in analyzing Obama's failures in this, his latest war. He is a commander-in-chief who refuses to command. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Thursday, March 24, 2011
Why he dithered
I have regularly expressed my contempt for Mr. Obama's dithering over the past month, while a democratic movement bled on the sands of North Africa. But here is Fouad Ajami in the Wall Street Journal with an analysis of the president's failure that is more, um, nuanced than mine:
Everywhere Mr. Obama looked, he saw Iraq. We couldn't rescue Tripoli and Benghazi because of what we had witnessed in Fallujah and Sadr City. Iraq was Mr. Obama's entry into the foreign world, it was his opposition to that war that gave him a sense of worldliness and gravitas. He had made much of being "a student of history." But history didn't stretch far for him, and in a man who claimed affinity with distant peoples and places, there was a heavy dosage of parochialism. It was history's odd timing: A great historical rupture in the Arab world, bearing within it the promise of remaking a flawed political tradition that knew no middle ground between despotism and nihilistic violence, happened on the watch of an American president proud of his deliberateness and his detachment from history's passions.Worth a read. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Monday, March 21, 2011
Hope for Libya
Here's one less tank of Gadaffi's. Let's hope its destruction came soon enough. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Saturday, March 19, 2011
Can he vote 'present' by absentee ballot?
So here's the score: the French stepped up to the plate. (Remember how we used to mock them? "Ah, the French!" we would giggle. "Always there when they need us!") The British of course stepped up to the plate. Heck, the Arab League stepped up to the plate. And even the United Nations Security Council stepped up to the plate, albeit with five abstentions. As for the most powerful man in the world, the forty-fourth president of the United States--well, Mr Obama skipped off to Brazil. Only then (and evidently only after he was prodded by Hillary Clinton) did he let it be known that he was, after all, in support of hard measures in Libya.
If there has been a more contemptible performance by an American president in the past hundred years, I can't think of what it could possibly be. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
If there has been a more contemptible performance by an American president in the past hundred years, I can't think of what it could possibly be. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Thursday, March 17, 2011
Reviews, options, consultations, discussions
The word from White House dot gov:
Readout of President Obama's meeting with his national security team on LibyaWell, that's a huge relief. For a month now, I feared that the United States of America wasn't going to do anything to help the Libyan democracy movement. Not to worry! Our best minds are reviewing the situation. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
At today’s meeting, the President and his national security team reviewed the situation in Libya and options to increase pressure on Gaddafi. In particular, the conversation focused on efforts at the United Nations and potential UN Security Council actions, as well as ongoing consultations with Arab and European partners.
The President instructed his team to continue to fully engage in the discussions at the United Nations, NATO and with partners and organizations in the region.
Tuesday, March 15, 2011
Time indeed!
One of the neat things about subscribing to The New Yorker is the email that arrives most every week with a preview of the coming issue's articles, with a link to the online edition in case you can't wait to read one of them. Thus it was that I hurried to investigate "David Remick on Obama and the Middle East." (Not available to non-subscribers.) I just naturally assumed that it dealt with the great issue of the day--Libya's murdering of its own people--and it does in fact contain a clarion call for action: "It is time for President Obama to speak clearly and firmly."
Alas, as I should have guessed, Mr. Remick is not calling for action against an enemy--an enemy of the U.S. and of democracy--but against a friend, and the only true democracy in the region, to wit: Israel. Wouldn't you know it? Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Alas, as I should have guessed, Mr. Remick is not calling for action against an enemy--an enemy of the U.S. and of democracy--but against a friend, and the only true democracy in the region, to wit: Israel. Wouldn't you know it? Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Sunday, March 13, 2011
Actions, options, costs, benefits ...
"When it comes to U.S. military actions, whether it's a no-fly zone or other options, you've got to balance costs versus benefits," Mr. Obama said. "And, you know, I don't take those decisions lightly."
It would be fairer to say that he doesn't take those decisions at all. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Thursday, March 10, 2011
Not to decide is also a decision (Sartre)
Reports the New York Times this morning: "President Obama’s national security team met at the White House on Wednesday to discuss how to oust the Libyan leader, including the possible imposition of a no-flight zone, but made no decisions, according to the White House press secretary, Jay Carney." Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Tuesday, March 8, 2011
Qadaffi faces a range of potential options!
Remember Hillary Clinton's campaign ad in which the White House phone rings at three o'clock in the morning? Well, that phone started ringing weeks ago, and it hasn't been answered yet. Here's the president's latest declaration on whether or not we should aid the Libyan rebels:
President Obama, appearing Monday morning with Australia’s prime minister, tried to raise the pressure on Colonel Qaddafi further by talking about “a range of potential options, including potential military options” against the embattled Libyan leader.Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Sunday, March 6, 2011
The missing F-22
I have great respect for Robert Gates, whom Dubya appointed and Obama retained as Secretary of Defense, but I am puzzled his arguments with respect to the F-22 air-superiority fighter and our unwillingness or inability to enforce a no-fly zone over rebel-held Libya. Here's how it goes:
1) We don't need and can't afford more F-22s than the 187 now on order. Better that the money should be spent on the smaller, cheaper, slower, but more versatile F-35, which is tailor-made for the sort of counter-insurgencies that now challenge us. One reason the F-22 is so expensive is that it is nearly invulnerable to ground fire, because the enemy can't see it or, seeing it, can't hit it.
2) The United States couldn't (or anyhow shouldn't) attempt to enforce a no-fly zone in Libya because we would first have to destroy Libyan anti-aircraft defenses, and that would require more airplanes than could be flown off a single aircraft carrier.
How does that compute? Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
1) We don't need and can't afford more F-22s than the 187 now on order. Better that the money should be spent on the smaller, cheaper, slower, but more versatile F-35, which is tailor-made for the sort of counter-insurgencies that now challenge us. One reason the F-22 is so expensive is that it is nearly invulnerable to ground fire, because the enemy can't see it or, seeing it, can't hit it.
2) The United States couldn't (or anyhow shouldn't) attempt to enforce a no-fly zone in Libya because we would first have to destroy Libyan anti-aircraft defenses, and that would require more airplanes than could be flown off a single aircraft carrier.
How does that compute? Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Wednesday, March 2, 2011
The UN speaks, Libya trembles
Wow. The UN Human Rights Council (as it's now called, since the earlier Human Rights Commission became an embarrassment) actually suspended one of its members yesterday. Boo hoo, Muammar Gadhafi! This is the same Human Rights Council whose draft report contains these words of praise from what blogger James Tarranto calls "a rogue's gallery of tyrannies":
Sudan noted the country's positive experience in achieving a high school enrolment rate and improvements in the education of women. The Syrian Arab Republic praised the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya [that is, Libya] for its serious commitment to and interaction with the Human Rights Council and its mechanisms. . . . North Korea praised the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya for its achievements in the protection of human rights. . . . Palestine commended the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya for the consultations held with civil society in the preparation of the national report. . . . Saudi Arabia commended the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya's achievements in its constitutional, legislative and institutional frameworks. . . . Venezuela acknowledged the efforts of the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya to promote economic, social and cultural rights, especially those of children. . . . Cuba commended the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya for the progress made. . . . Myanmar commended the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya for its economic and social progress.To their shame, Gadhafi's thuggish regime also got sweet words from Canada, Australia, and even the U.S. I suppose it's too much to hope that there could ever be a revolution at Turtle Bay? Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Tuesday, March 1, 2011
Viva Libya libre!
Enough already: it's time for the United States to extend recognition to the provisional government of Libya. It's just plain humiliating that we should stand by, thumbs in all the wrong places, waiting for the United Nations, when France and Britain are leading the way with actions that really bite the dictator in his softer extremities. There's a civil war in Libya! The good guys are winning! Please, Mr. Obama, don't just stand there gazing helplessly toward Turtle Bay: do something. Show the world that you deserve that Nobel Peace Prize you got so effortlessly. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Monday, February 28, 2011
Looking on the bright side
Whenever the cloud of revolution appears on the horizon, the New York Times famously sees only the silver lining. All those kindle "agrarian reformers" of the past, who turned into murderous thugs! The Gray Lady is at it again, as in this story by Scott Shane:
For nearly two decades, the leaders of Al Qaeda have denounced the Arab world’s dictators as heretics and puppets of the West and called for their downfall. Now, people in country after country have risen to topple their leaders — and Al Qaeda has played absolutely no role.Of course that's true as far as it goes. But Mr. Shane goes on to a rather breathtaking either/or:
Will the terrorist network shrivel slowly to irrelevance? Or will it find a way to exploit the chaos produced by political upheaval and the disappointment that will inevitably follow hopes now raised so high?Shrivel to irrelevance? Well, one can only hope. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Labels:
al Qaeda,
Egypt,
journos,
Libya,
revolution
Saturday, February 26, 2011
Chums
How sweet it is! The thugs are falling left and right. Here in happier times (for them, if not for their peole) were (left to right) Tunisian dictator Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali, Yemeni dictator Ali Abdullah Saleh, Libyan dictator Moammar Qaddafi, and Egyptian dictator Hosni Mubarak. Two down and two to go! (Why is it that western media insist on giving these men the deferential title of "president"?) Blue skies! -- Dan Ford
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
