Showing posts with label assassination. Show all posts
Showing posts with label assassination. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Of drone strikes and assassinations

I have mused before about the queasy feeling I get when the United States of America tries to kill its enemies with targeted assassination, as opposed to an up-front invasion that kills a whole lot more people, both ours and theirs. Today in the NYT, Robert Wright gives the assassination question a good airing. (I didn't know who Mr. Wright was, either. Turns out he's a senior fellow at the New America Foundation. And no, I don't know what that is, either.) He writes:
"President Obama, who during his first year in office oversaw more drone strikes in Pakistan than occurred during the entire Bush presidency, last week surpassed his predecessor in a second respect: he authorized the assassination of an American — Anwar al-Awlaki, the radical Imam who after 9/11 moved from Virginia to Yemen, a base from which he inspires such people as the Fort Hood shooter and the would-be underwear bomber."
It does seem that hands-off assassinations are the hallmark of Democratic administrations, while Republicans send in 3rd Infantry Division. The Bush boys, father and son, both invaded Iraq, while Bill Clinton made a regular practice of firing cruise missiles at training camps that proved empty and chemical plants that proved to be aspirin factories, or so we were told at the time. Mr. Obama seems to favor Mr. Clinton's policy, and it is certainly one that costs fewer lives. But, as Mr. Wright points out, "Students of the law might raise a couple of questions." Of course they might! That's what students of law do best. Still, they are questions that deserve an airing--and I note uneasily that among the folks who agree with the leftish Mr. Wright is the rightish Bill Lind, whom I quoted on the same subject here recently.

Mr. Wright lays out his objections, and concludes: "I’m not sure I’d want to pay these prices even for a strategy that helped us in the war against terrorism." But of course he hasn't really paid any price, including the price of standing still for the next terrorist attack. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford

Monday, March 15, 2010

Mistah Kurtz, he blogging

The NYT has a wonderful Rick's Place story in today's paper. ('I'm shocked--shocked!--to find that gambling's going on in here.') It involves a covert operation that supposedly used an innocent hearts-and-minds program to turn up information that was used to track and kill bad guys in Afghanistan and Pakistan. It's all very complex, as such ops tend to be (remember Iran-Contra?), and there are two very funny kinks to it. One is Afpax Insider, a website run by the program. By all means take a look and see your tax dollars at work.

The other kink is the Rick's Place moment: toward the end of the NYT story, we learn that (wait for it!) the Gray Lady herself hired this outfit to rescue one of her own reporters. As it happened, he escaped by himself, but the symmetry is wonderful. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford

Thursday, February 25, 2010

The assassination conundrum

I once blogged about the discomfort I felt when a remotely piloted drone aircraft targets an individual for death, or a team of Special Operatives hunts down and kills someone. That’s more akin to assassination than warfare as usually practiced, and I contrasted it with the glee I feel when the US Marines come crashing ashore to accomplish the same deed. Somehow, taking the bad guy out in a full frontal assault is okay, while dispatching a Hellfire missile or killer team seems evil, or anyhow not the work of gentlemen.

So it is with the death of Mahmoud al-Mabhouh in Dubai earlier this month. The man abducted and killed two Israeli soldiers, among other activities. Now either what he did in that instance was either an act of war or a cold-blooded murder. If an act of war, then his assassination by what we assume were Israeli agents is no less problematical. And if murder, how can we possibly object to his receiving the same treatment in his turn? It’s not as if Hamas is going to bring him to justice, or the statelet of Dubai, and certainly not the International Criminal Court.

Yet the BBC among other western news outlets report on the assassination as if Mr al-Mabhouh were the victim and his assassins the criminals. Partly this is the result of a reflexive anti-Israel bias, and partly the West’s confusion over how to respond to an enemy who wears no uniform and follows no code of war. Blue skies! – Dan Ford